Skip to main content

Grammarphobia: True north, literal and figurative

Grammarphobia: True north, literal and figurative

Read this and other similar posts at www.grammarphobia.com.

Thanks for reading Capturing Voices! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Q: I am wondering about the origin of the phrase “true north.” When did it show up in English? And when did Christians begin using it metaphorically in referring to Jesus Christ as their “true North”?

A: As far as we can tell, the phrase “true north” was first used metaphorically in reference to Jesus in the 19th century. The earliest example we’ve seen is from a book for Christians who question their faith by a pastor who questioned his.

In Christianity and the Science of Manhood: A Book for Questioners (1873), Minot Judson Savage says Jesus “is the first great leader of history who, by the power of his personal love, has drawn thousands of men out of and away from their most fascinating passions, and their dearest sins.”

“He has discovered,” Savage adds, “the secret of the human heart, and so drawn it into magnetic sympathy with his own, that in all its variations and vibrations, it is ever settling nearer and nearer to his true north.”

In the preface, he says the book was “born of doubt and conflict.” It was published a year after he left the Congregational Church to become a Unitarian because he “found it impossible to rest in tradition” and “felt compelled to seek a reasonable basis on which to stand.” He was a well-known Unitarian preacher in New England in the late 19th century.

Despite that early example, the figurative use of “true north” in reference to Jesus was relatively rare until the late 20th century. And the phrase is still not common enough to be included in any of the ten standard dictionaries we regularly consult. It’s just defined literally as the geographic north as opposed to the magnetic north.

Nor is this figurative sense of “true north” found in the Oxford English Dictionary, the most comprehensive English etymological reference. It has only one definition for the term: “north determined by the earth’s axis of rotation (as opposed to magnetic north).”

The OED’s earliest citation is from a 16th-century mathematical treatise: “Of the Variacion of the Compas, from true Northe” (in The Elements of Geometrie of the Most Ancient Philosopher Euclide, 1570, by Henry Billingsley, a translation from the Greek of Euclid’s work).

We’ll end with a metaphorical example from Mere Christianity, a 1952 book by C. S. Lewis, based on radio broadcasts he made during World War II. Here’s how he describes two people undecided about God:

“Their free will is trembling inside them like the needle of a compass. But this is a needle that can choose. It can point to its true North; but it need not. Will the needle swing round, and settle, and point to God?”

Thanks for reading Capturing Voices! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Grammarphobia: True north, literal and figurative

Grammarphobia: True north, literal and figurative

Read this and other similar posts at www.grammarphobia.com.

Thanks for reading Capturing Voices! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Q: I am wondering about the origin of the phrase “true north.” When did it show up in English? And when did Christians begin using it metaphorically in referring to Jesus Christ as their “true North”?

A: As far as we can tell, the phrase “true north” was first used metaphorically in reference to Jesus in the 19th century. The earliest example we’ve seen is from a book for Christians who question their faith by a pastor who questioned his.

In Christianity and the Science of Manhood: A Book for Questioners (1873), Minot Judson Savage says Jesus “is the first great leader of history who, by the power of his personal love, has drawn thousands of men out of and away from their most fascinating passions, and their dearest sins.”

“He has discovered,” Savage adds, “the secret of the human heart, and so drawn it into magnetic sympathy with his own, that in all its variations and vibrations, it is ever settling nearer and nearer to his true north.”

In the preface, he says the book was “born of doubt and conflict.” It was published a year after he left the Congregational Church to become a Unitarian because he “found it impossible to rest in tradition” and “felt compelled to seek a reasonable basis on which to stand.” He was a well-known Unitarian preacher in New England in the late 19th century.

Despite that early example, the figurative use of “true north” in reference to Jesus was relatively rare until the late 20th century. And the phrase is still not common enough to be included in any of the ten standard dictionaries we regularly consult. It’s just defined literally as the geographic north as opposed to the magnetic north.

Nor is this figurative sense of “true north” found in the Oxford English Dictionary, the most comprehensive English etymological reference. It has only one definition for the term: “north determined by the earth’s axis of rotation (as opposed to magnetic north).”

The OED’s earliest citation is from a 16th-century mathematical treatise: “Of the Variacion of the Compas, from true Northe” (in The Elements of Geometrie of the Most Ancient Philosopher Euclide, 1570, by Henry Billingsley, a translation from the Greek of Euclid’s work).

We’ll end with a metaphorical example from Mere Christianity, a 1952 book by C. S. Lewis, based on radio broadcasts he made during World War II. Here’s how he describes two people undecided about God:

“Their free will is trembling inside them like the needle of a compass. But this is a needle that can choose. It can point to its true North; but it need not. Will the needle swing round, and settle, and point to God?”

Thanks for reading Capturing Voices! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

More sentences!

More sentences!

If you’re a fan of Slow Horses, you are familiar with Mick Herron’s work. The man has a way with words. I’ve been reading the Slough House series, and much to my partner’s chagrin, I can’t read it quietly. I can read for about a minute before I am compelled to read it aloud. The sentences he builds can be little electric shocks to my brain!.

Here are a couple from a different series of his, the Oxford Series.

Thanks for reading Capturing Voices! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

FYI, Merriam-Webster says prelapsarian refers to the time before the fall of man: characteristic of or belonging to the time or state before the fall of humankind.

Here’s another one, so evocative of driving into a city that I can’t get the picture out of my mind.

On the other hand, there’s AI transcription:

WW2 veteran, talking about using a .30-caliber carbine.

AI transcript: Thank God I never had to fart.

Actual transcript: Thank God I never had to fire it.

AI transcript: There was a guy in a big white town truck 

Actual transcript: There was a guy in a big five-ton truck.

AI transcript: He wore a shoulder. Warden was lost.

Actual Transcript: He was washed overboard and was lost.  (He wore a shoulder????????)

AI transcript: “. . . And when you ask her why she did that, she replied that pennies make Nichols, Nichols make quarters. quarters make dollars…”

AI transcript: I was born in Cleveland, Ohio. Auschwitz 12, 1924.

Actual Transcript: I was born in Cleveland, Ohio. August 12, 1924.

Thanks for reading Capturing Voices! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

More sentences!

More sentences!

If you’re a fan of Slow Horses, you are familiar with Mick Herron’s work. The man has a way with words. I’ve been reading the Slough House series, and much to my partner’s chagrin, I can’t read it quietly. I can read for about a minute before I am compelled to read it aloud. The sentences he builds can be little electric shocks to my brain!.

Here are a couple from a different series of his, the Oxford Series.

Thanks for reading Capturing Voices! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

FYI, Merriam-Webster says prelapsarian refers to the time before the fall of man: characteristic of or belonging to the time or state before the fall of humankind.

Here’s another one, so evocative of driving into a city that I can’t get the picture out of my mind.

On the other hand, there’s AI transcription:

WW2 veteran, talking about using a .30-caliber carbine.

AI transcript: Thank God I never had to fart.

Actual transcript: Thank God I never had to fire it.

AI transcript: There was a guy in a big white town truck 

Actual transcript: There was a guy in a big five-ton truck.

AI transcript: He wore a shoulder. Warden was lost.

Actual Transcript: He was washed overboard and was lost.  (He wore a shoulder????????)

AI transcript: “. . . And when you ask her why she did that, she replied that pennies make Nichols, Nichols make quarters. quarters make dollars…”

AI transcript: I was born in Cleveland, Ohio. Auschwitz 12, 1924.

Actual Transcript: I was born in Cleveland, Ohio. August 12, 1924.

Thanks for reading Capturing Voices! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Oral History Manager, Abraham Lincoln Presidential Library and Museum

Oral History Manager, Abraham Lincoln Presidential Library and Museum

Deadline February 7, 2024 The Abraham Lincoln Presidential Library & Musuem (ALPLM) is hiring an Exec II – Oral Historian Manager. The incumbent will work closely with the Director of Research and Interpretation to document, preserve, make available the stories of Illinoisans. The ideal candidate will have a background in conducting and managing oral history […]

Southwest Oral History Association Conference

Southwest Oral History Association Conference

Deadline extended to February 2, 2024           The Southwest Oral History Association promotes an ever-shifting place and people-making storytelling capacity throughout time and across intergenerational consciousness. Through history and memory, we unearth and combat repressive settler ideologies. Just as both roots and branches strenghthen a tree, stories, memories and reflection center […]